Mountain Buzz banner

1 - 18 of 18 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
It's been too long since I've been on the water, therefore my mind goes where it always does..."I should buy another boat!" ...it says. That all too often tends to be my ill-advised rememdy to cabin fever.

So packrafts- They will fill a niche I do not have covered. I am a fisherman first and a boater second (although do both most weeks at the same time) and I think one could serve me well for a few certain areas. These streams would be mostly class I maybe II with shallow shoals for the most part. I envision the packraft expediting my exit back to the car or accessing the otherside of streams in spots I cannot wade nor effectively traverse.

I don't feel like I can justify the cost of an Alpacka to myself...so I look towards the NRS packraft.

The NRS Pros I see:
-2 tube chambers (vs 1 for the alpackas)
-Comes with floor, doubles as sleeping pad
-Larger than most (all?) alpackas
-Alot cheaper than Alpackas

The Cons:
[email protected] 200lbs I fear the tube design will have me floating "wheelies" all the time- alpackas have the pointy area in the back for the extra flotation for the torso
-Fewer options/ accessories, like no sprayskirt (not sure I want a sprayskirt tho)
-Apparently the NRS D-rings are total crap
-NRS is 7.4 lbs, slightly heavier than the alpackas (I'm no ultralite backpacker though)
-Maybe too large (being 5'9" I prolly will have trouble bracing against the front tubes.)
-Sounds as if they pack larger than Alpackas

So as you can see, many of the cons are "trivial" to a point. Anyone own an NRS packraft that would care to chime in?

Do you use it more or less than you thought, are they fragile etc. Talk me into or out of one of these. (or sell me one of yours)

Thanks as always buzzards
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,984 Posts
I do not have the answers to your question.

But am interested in following this thread.

Lately I have been researching the Alpacka set up and am totally amazed at what they can do and how little they weight.

Don't know about the NRS versions but the Alpacka's seem to be really light weight if you are carrying them plus fishing gear.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
787 Posts
I saw an Alpacka at a lake in the Eagle Cap Wilderness last summer, they hiked it in a fished the lake with it for a few days. The quality was stout, it floated nicely with a variety of people trying it out and looked like it tracked well. I don't think you would go wrong with one. I have not seen the NRS boat in person.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
223 Posts
I was interested too, mainly just curiosity. And since i'm not a cat, it seemed harmless. Material is different and supposedly fairly strong. Thought a few threads had been hit with this subject. The NRS wasn't highly reviewed, and had some complaints about durability, even on reviews on their website. Seems the Alpackas have a good rep and pretty good durability.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
765 Posts
Cant comment on the NRS but I have an Alpacka Denali llama. Mine has the cargo fly to store gear inside. They're remarkable little boats really. Very lightweight and durable. The big butt design(stability) and the skirt,stowage ability impress me the most. I'm a somewhat big guy and no wheelies for me,in it. They track extremely well,I thought,in the short times I've had them on the water. I Took them on The Hoh and Queets river. not too technical but they're glacial rivers so fast with a strong cold current. Almost felt like I was in a hardshell boat. They're not super comfy for long periods of time but most little boats aren't either. Without going into it,I'd def take Alpacka over NRS. If you plan on hiking long distances with it(and that's what they're meant for) you'll be happy you went with something lighter that packs down smaller. Cause pfd's,helmet,paddles,food,water,fish poles etc all start to pileup quick. Lightweight is the name of the game with alpacas. If you're not doing much whitewater you probably wouldn't need the fancy WW spray deck. Their convertible one should be suitable.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
38 Posts
Do it and don't look back

I love my alpackas, I have run heavy class 3 and love how well they handle it. I have the denali for my main backpacker, a alpacka for smaller friends, and a fjord explorer with the rowing kit for fishing calm rivers and mountain lakes. I have the cruiser deck on all three but may have a white water deck put on the Denali so I can start running some bigger stuff with it. If I had to chose just one though, it would be the fjord hands down for its versatility, it has replaced all of my hard shell and sot kayaks at the lakes for fishing for all but the biggest lakes where paddling long distances in a short time is priority. It does almost as well in the white water as the Denali but has more room for gear and tracks better too.

I wouldn't waste my money on the NRS unit, I couldn't find one good review for it when I decided to buy something in that class. Be careful though, they are addictive little things and before you know it you have a fleet. It is kinda nice keeping on in the car or truck too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
482 Posts
Look at Jacks Plastic in Aztec New Mexico

It's been too long since I've been on the water, therefore my mind goes where it always does..."I should buy another boat!" ...it says. That all too often tends to be my ill-advised rememdy to cabin fever.

So packrafts- They will fill a niche I do not have covered. I am a fisherman first and a boater second (although do both most weeks at the same time) and I think one could serve me well for a few certain areas. These streams would be mostly class I maybe II with shallow shoals for the most part. I envision the packraft expediting my exit back to the car or accessing the otherside of streams in spots I cannot wade nor effectively traverse.

I don't feel like I can justify the cost of an Alpacka to myself...so I look towards the NRS packraft.

The NRS Pros I see:
-2 tube chambers (vs 1 for the alpackas)
-Comes with floor, doubles as sleeping pad
-Larger than most (all?) alpackas
-Alot cheaper than Alpackas

The Cons:
[email protected] 200lbs I fear the tube design will have me floating "wheelies" all the time- alpackas have the pointy area in the back for the extra flotation for the torso
-Fewer options/ accessories, like no sprayskirt (not sure I want a sprayskirt tho)
-Apparently the NRS D-rings are total crap
-NRS is 7.4 lbs, slightly heavier than the alpackas (I'm no ultralite backpacker though)
-Maybe too large (being 5'9" I prolly will have trouble bracing against the front tubes.)
-Sounds as if they pack larger than Alpackas

So as you can see, many of the cons are "trivial" to a point. Anyone own an NRS packraft that would care to chime in?

Do you use it more or less than you thought, are they fragile etc. Talk me into or out of one of these. (or sell me one of yours)

Thanks as always buzzards
Ten fold improvement in quality over the N-Folks; Made in the NM USA
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
Ten fold improvement in quality over the N-Folks; Made in the NM USA
I don't see anything comparable @ JPW. The mosquito is much larger and heavier than I'm considering. Am I missing something?



Thanks tho guys, although I'm not sure I'm any closer to a decision eitherway.

I do like the concept of the alpackas...except they are 2x's as much $ for a boat that I suspect I may use 3x's a year....for that I feel like I can get away with being super easy on the crappy d-ring that everyone apparently rips off of the NRS.

Not worried about whitewater either...that's what the other 5 boats I have are for ;) !

...Still thinking!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
426 Posts
I've seen both the NRS and Alpackas in action. I have a number of friends with various generations of Alpackas and as stated, those boats are where it's at. Personally I'm waiting for the next generation of ww specific Alpacka to become available (hopefully spring 2014!) Having read what you intend to do with it, the NRS will be just fine. It's small(ish), and it floats. Unless you intend to do more of what the Alpackas excel at, then you probably won't get your $$$ worth just putting around and ferrying across small streams.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,984 Posts
For what it is worth, I used to fish a lot of high lakes in CO areas. Short hike in not long. And, used a old town pack canoe. Felt good to have that royalex between me and deep cold lake water.

If I were still doing that kind of fishing, I would save up and get a real Alpaka just for the safety factor and piece of mind. Do some research via google on the Alpaka versus NRS and make up your own mind tho.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
I would save up and get a real Alpaka just for the safety factor and piece of mind. Do some research via google on the Alpaka versus NRS and make up your own mind tho.

See I feel like the NRS would be safer with the 2 chamber design (with all things the same it certainly would be)...and my google research shows that the NRS failures seem to all be in the D-rings. I have heard that it is nice that the NRS floor keeps your butt outta the water.

I will say I somehow just noticed the Alpacka scout, which is about the same $ as the NRS and is less than 1/2 the weight...but again, no floor and no seat and 1 chamber still makes me wonder...it is smaller also but I was worried about the interior length of the NRS.

With this new revelation I maybe should just decide if I will use a packraft enough to get one.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
I've seen both the NRS and Alpackas in action. I have a number of friends with various generations of Alpackas and as stated, those boats are where it's at.

What specifically makes you say this? In what ways do the alpackas excel?

Having read what you intend to do with it, the NRS will be just fine.

Which was my initial thought, hence my original leanings towards the NRS- I found a good deal on one too I think.


Thanks for some real world comparison- that is what i need!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
62 Posts
I have both the NRS and an Alpaca. The Alpaca is unquestionably better. That said, I have run plenty of stuff (up to class IV) with the NRS. D rings are still in tact somehow.

For the Alpaca owners out there - one thing I discovered is that the NRS floor fits nearly perfect in the bottom of an Alpaca Denali boat. Is a huge upgrade in my view in terms of comfort and way better than a therma-arrest.

NRS will sell the floors separate. I ordered one to use with my Alpaca in the event that some else I am boating with uses my NRS Packraft.

One more thing. There is another Packraft company starting up out of denver. I have seen the boats on a few rivers over the past couple years: http://kokopelliraftco.com
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
668 Posts
...For the Alpaca owners out there - one thing I discovered is that the NRS floor fits nearly perfect in the bottom of an Alpaca Denali boat. Is a huge upgrade in my view in terms of comfort and way better than a therma-arrest.

NRS will sell the floors separate. I ordered one to use with my Alpaca in the event that some else I am boating with uses my NRS Packraft...
That sounds like the way to go IMO. I've been looking at getting one myself, and if I can scrape together the money, that's rob ably what I will do.

On the issue of weight, the Alpacka isn't that much different when you compare apples to apples. Without the floor that comes with the NRS, the difference is less than a half a pound, or one less beer in the boat with you... LOL

The Denali and a couple of the others also do come with a seat and a backrest, just not a floor.

So, for the difference in quality (from what I've read here and elsewhere anyway), the Alpacka seems to be the better of the two right now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
462 Posts
Discussion Starter #18
A 3/4 thermarest can be used as a floor in a Denali Alpacka.

I have a 3/4 pro-lite but I worry about the stress that would put on it.


Man I really coulda used a packraft Monday...might hafta get one just for this creek. Woulda saved me a 4mile walk out too.

I'm close to a decision...but I also realize I want new oars! Hmmm...decisions, decisions.
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Top