Yo Fart,
I've been paddling a villain for 2 seasons now. I'd give the jackson outfitting a thumbs up. The seat and thigh connections are great. I feel like they are superior to the nomads and grandes I have paddled in the past.
The shock absorbing bulkhead is an ankle saver when you piton. Big safety improvement in my mind.
The rope system takes a little getting used to, but I haven't found it to be a big deal. I have never had a rope pop out, but I do find that the ropes for the backband or the rope for the foam bulkhead can stretch out a little. If you tighted up the ropes in the eddy to what feels "right" and then launch into class V, you may find your backband a little loose after you paddle a rapid or two. I have adapted to this so that I cinch the ropes a nick tighter initially, they flex slightly once I start paddling, and the result is that I'm where I need to be. Very easy to adjust in the boat in an eddy too.
I have had ratchets fail on me on the river and I think that the rope system provides a simpler system with less parts to fail. If I had the option of a villain with a ratchet backband, I might choose it over the ropes, but its not a big enough issue to me that I have ever thought about trying to modify the boat, and I have never had an issue while paddling.
The main thing is how you like the hull and how the villain handles (awesome!), and how well the boat and outfitting fits you (awesome for me too).
Jackson definitely has some detractors on the outfitting, but after numerous boats that left my feet numb, I find the villain to be the most comfortable creek boat I have paddled.
Good luck.