Mountain Buzz banner
21 - 40 of 46 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
266 Posts
I'm done with deep cycle AGM batteries, as in my experience they just don't provide consistent voltage once you start drawing them past 50% (especially for inverters). Recently replaced a lackluster Duracell AGM Ultra 100AH with a 100AH Renogy in the tiny home, and its been an absolute game-changer in terms of working capacity.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #22 · (Edited)
I'm done with deep cycle AGM batteries, as in my experience they just don't provide consistent voltage once you start drawing them past 50% (especially for inverters). Recently replaced a lackluster Duracell AGM Ultra 100AH with a 100AH Renogy in the tiny home, and its been an absolute game-changer in terms of working capacity.
I know you are correct, and I have been contorting myself to avoid building either a bank of LiFePO4 batteries/cells in a dry box with a battery management system and a Bluetooth temperature system, an LiFePO4 server rack battery size situation in a dry box (how I regulate the temperature here I am not sure), a large 200+ Ah 12V solution (Xantrex - Xantrex Lithium Ion Battery 240Ah 12Vdc #BDX20145 (emarineinc.com) ), or some other such dollar sucking device. I also remain concerned about temperature extremes, hot and cold in their performance, and how I set up a DC-DC charger solution as I don't think I need to invert and then charge another DC portable battery/power supply.

Makes me think I will never get myself a boat at this rate, although wondering if that is smart anyway because of climate change and drought.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
266 Posts
I know you are correct, and I have been contorting myself to avoid building either a bank of LiFePO4 batteries/cells in a dry box with a battery management system and a Bluetooth temperature system, an LiFePO4 server rack battery size situation in a dry box (how I regulate the temperature here I am not sure), a large 200+ Ah 12V solution (Xantrex - Xantrex Lithium Ion Battery 240Ah 12Vdc #BDX20145 (emarineinc.com) ), or some other such dollar sucking device. I also remain concerned about temperature extremes, hot and cold in their performance, and how I set up a DC-DC charger solution as I don't think I need to invert and then charge another DC portable battery/power supply.

Makes me think I will never get myself a boat at this rate, although wondering if that is smart anyway because of climate change and drought.
Hmmm...sounds more like you're putting together residential system on a (floating) second home, the entire cost of which then becomes eligible for those sweet sweet solar tax credits ;)

I'm all about DIY and homebrew, but boy howdy when it comes to solar/power/electricity/batteries/etc will always spend the extra bucks on reputable brands and prebuilt (warranteed) products if only to minimize the risk (liability) of fire. In the end though, maybe there's at least some solace in that old adage suggesting any boat is merely a hole in the water into which money is poured.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #26 ·
Hmmm...sounds more like you're putting together residential system on a (floating) second home, the entire cost of which then becomes eligible for those sweet sweet solar tax credits ;)

I'm all about DIY and homebrew, but boy howdy when it comes to solar/power/electricity/batteries/etc will always spend the extra bucks on reputable brands and prebuilt (warranteed) products if only to minimize the risk (liability) of fire. In the end though, maybe there's at least some solace in that old adage suggesting any boat is merely a hole in the water into which money is poured.
If I take my father who is close to 80, the one who walked me down Bright Angel Trail to Indian Garden at 4 years old, and to the river at 6, the one who took me from the top down to Vasey’s Paradise at 16 when it wasn’t called canyoneering then, the one who let me row an 18’ Sotar on my first go down the River (yes, I popped out on House Rock…now I run that one the best), the one who gave me my love for the Canyon, I need to cover 2 CPAPs. They draw about an amp each, peak wattage at 27.

I know I am flying too close to the sun to add an Engel fridge/freezer, and to film a movie
 

· Registered
Joined
·
699 Posts
Ok, so most folks don't like "W" on the river and a since a wind turbine is out of the picture - go low. If your on a fast moving river and your ir your camp is close to higher velocity flow close to shore how about some of the water turbines that are starting to show up on the market? Don't know if they would produce enough charging amps but working thru the night might be enough to do the job. Just thinking out loud.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
810 Posts
A consideration with wind..

If you're planning on it being up while you're rowing, and it's "flat water", any energy it produces has to come out of the net power that you're putting into the oars. The energy output = net input from your calories + losses from wind resistance.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
469 Posts
Mounted the panels on top of my Bimini, I run the panels in series to a mppt charge controller. Allows the batteries to charge even in the shade...
This system worked wonderful for running my misting system on my grand trip this June. Charged my speaker, phone, headlamp, and fan for sleeping...
The 50ah lithium battery is pretty lightweight and fits in the ammo can perfectly. The system is awesome and completely waterproof.
Solar power Solar energy Solar panel Gas Tints and shades
 

· Registered
Joined
·
469 Posts
If I take my father who is close to 80, the one who walked me down Bright Angel Trail to Indian Garden at 4 years old, and to the river at 6, the one who took me from the top down to Vasey’s Paradise at 16 when it wasn’t called canyoneering then, the one who let me row an 18’ Sotar on my first go down the River (yes, I popped out on House Rock…now I run that one the best), the one who gave me my love for the Canyon, I need to cover 2 CPAPs. They draw about an amp each, peak wattage at 27.

I know I am flying too close to the sun to add an Engel fridge/freezer, and to film a movie
This power demand can only be maintained on a motor trip.... the new tohatsu motors have a 21 Amp alternator, charging that much stuff and running a freezer is only going to be workable on a snout or larger boat...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #32 ·
A consideration with wind..

If you're planning on it being up while you're rowing, and it's "flat water", any energy it produces has to come out of the net power that you're putting into the oars. The energy output = net input from your calories + losses from wind resistance.
Given the issues with dunking in the drink even with large splash, my sense is that a small marine marine turbine (small is relative, to produce any power it has to be about a meter in diameter) is an in camp set up on the back of the boat. My logic being that one is in camp more than on the water statistically.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #33 ·
Mounted the panels on top of my Bimini, I run the panels in series to a mppt charge controller. Allows the batteries to charge even in the shade...
This system worked wonderful for running my misting system on my grand trip this June. Charged my speaker, phone, headlamp, and fan for sleeping...
The 50ah lithium battery is pretty lightweight and fits in the ammo can perfectly. The system is awesome and completely waterproof.
View attachment 83291
this is a sweet set up, with superior panels. No issues with excess temps?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #34 ·
Was gonna say "why worry about a fire when you're surrounded by water". Then remembered what lithium does when it meets water...

Has anyone had any mishaps with those bigger battery banks and splashes / flips?
This is one thing I have been trying to engineer. I look at items such as EG4-WP Waterproof Lithium Battery | 48V 100AH | Bluetooth - Signature Solar and sense that in a dry box within a dry box it is doable. I am considering how composites may make this more lightweight as in a marine application.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #35 ·
This power demand can only be maintained on a motor trip.... the new tohatsu motors have a 21 Amp alternator, charging that much stuff and running a freezer is only going to be workable on a snout or larger boat...
No question this is the "how it has been done" answer. Two each 200 W Renogy flexible panels mounted on a piece of fiberglass over a flexible core while on the water covering the back of the gear/boat, and a wind turbine in camp with 6 kWh battery bank capacity seems like it could possibly manage this as well. I would want to use my cousin's children and my grandchildren as my energy crew and camera crew.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #36 ·
Ok, so most folks don't like "W" on the river and a since a wind turbine is out of the picture - go low. If your on a fast moving river and your ir your camp is close to higher velocity flow close to shore how about some of the water turbines that are starting to show up on the market? Don't know if they would produce enough charging amps but working thru the night might be enough to do the job. Just thinking out loud.
Not doing the Debbie Downer buttttt…, the tether seems to be an issue with twisting, maintaining stability in the current also one problem as the river will want to do what it wants to do, silt seems to be a problem, and although I have looked at it up and down, looked at off the shelf solutions for farmers, and even thought about the ability to raise and lower a fixed system from a cataraft in the current, I can’t seem to come up with a stable solution in my mind that makes me want to consider even a beta test.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
469 Posts
No question this is the "how it has been done" answer. Two each 200 W Renogy flexible panels mounted on a piece of fiberglass over a flexible core while on the water covering the back of the gear/boat, and a wind turbine in camp with 6 kWh battery bank capacity seems like it could possibly manage this as well. I would want to use my cousin's children and my grandchildren as my energy crew and camera crew.
find a way to mount them to a Bimini top. best place for them to get sun, and possibly, set it up so when you drop the bimini they lay down on your gear pile. I think if you set your mind to running all that you will figure out a way to make it work. that 200AH lithium battery will be a must. keeping everything DC will improve efficiency as well.

I don't know how water proof those 12v freezers are, when I put one in my snout its going in an aluminum splash box what will keep it from getting drowned and splashed in the rapids.

300-400 watt solar system paired with your CPAPs will be fine, but im not sure about the freezer
 

· Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
Discussion Starter · #39 · (Edited)
find a way to mount them to a Bimini top. best place for them to get sun, and possibly, set it up so when you drop the bimini they lay down on your gear pile. I think if you set your mind to running all that you will figure out a way to make it work. that 200AH lithium battery will be a must. keeping everything DC will improve efficiency as well.

I don't know how water proof those 12v freezers are, when I put one in my snout its going in an aluminum splash box what will keep it from getting drowned and splashed in the rapids.

300-400 watt solar system paired with your CPAPs will be fine, but im not sure about the freezer
Finding two newer batteries on sale as I was looking at building one. Epoch and Roy Pow have ridiculously low prices with battery heater, Bluetooth, BMS, 100 Ah for about $300. Four in series with a separate 200 A BMS (?) would be 100 Ah 48 and able to pull real amps, as well as 200 Ah equivalent to run two travel CPAPs for 16 days.

(
) (
)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
266 Posts
Was gonna say "why worry about a fire when you're surrounded by water". Then remembered what lithium does when it meets water...

Has anyone had any mishaps with those bigger battery banks and splashes / flips?
Since this hasn't come up yet, I thought its worth mentioning that bigger batteries and the process of charging them can generate a lot of heat (esp from 300-400 watts of solar power), which on the river also has to be contained in order to be waterproof and of course prevent explosive/unextinguishable fires in the case of lithium. So in an environment that is already hot like the GC, to me that could be troublesome since the gradient between the temp inside the waterproof box (already containing a battery in a box itself) and outside the waterproof box may not be large enough to promote the kind of cooling needed to prevent a thermal runaway. I think instead that two 50AH batteries in separate ammo cans with swappable (SAE?) connectors is probably a smarter move, as then have one to swap between and charge along with another to use during layover days.

As for battery heating, that's really only an issue with temps consistently below 41degrees. And on the flip side of the extreme temp problem if properly contained in a box, I'd doubt core battery temps would get that low unless left outside in very cold weather for a long period (like golf cars are).


Also in terms of a water turbine, the yield of power from natural momentum/motion would be incredible small. It's unfortunate, but thems the physics. D'oh!
 
21 - 40 of 46 Posts
Top