I have the large Deep Creek. It is a well built shelter and overall happy with it. It has many tie down points which is good and bad. When it is windy they all need to be secured or it will flap like crazy, some sites (like rocky)this is not always practical and it requires extra setup. I have the bug shelter but have never used it, it seems like it would work well on a perfectly level grassy surface ( like the promo video
. For sun and rain it has been great, when windy it can be stressful. I have also used the Sugarloaf and would get that instead if doing over. Easier to set up, always a bug shelter, mesh sides offer some protection from cold and rain too. Either way BA is a great company with great products.