astral green jacket is my favorite
I have the SWR training.
But, I choose the Green Jacket because of the fit.
It is low on flotation in my opinion for a rescue vest
At the same time the zipped up holder for the cowtail is really nice as it protects a bit from accidental catches
on the other hand
getting the pocket unzipped and the biner out of the pocket is not as easy as many other designs.
Bottom line just about everything in gear is a trade off one way or another.