I like the Teva Avator 2, but I don't know if they make them anymore. The heels needed to be cut down with a razor to fit into my Burn M but they are the best shoes I've had for creeking. Great protection, warm, and they stick to wet rocks.
I wouldn't wear a shoe that would fit into my playboat if I'm looking for a creeking shoe. I have had foot injuries from swimming class V a few times so I look for an extra burly creeking shoe.