Part I: When is it OK to Swim? & Pine Creek Incident - Mountain Buzz

Go Back   Mountain Buzz > Whitewater Boating > Whitewater Kayaking

Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-23-2011   #1
Hans's Avatar
Louisville, Colorado
Paddling Since: 1996
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 110
Part I: When is it OK to Swim? & Pine Creek Incident

Hello All!

As we are all waiting impatiently for our bountiful snow to start melting, the rivers to rise & hopefully flow all summer here in Colorado, I just wanted to touch on some safety issues that I was witnessing over the past weekend on the Ark. This is more intended for the newer paddlers out there, & of course are my own opinions, with the intent of keeping all safe on the river, please if some of the more veteran of you could not blast this, but rather offer constructive critique that would be appreciated as none of us benefit from injury or worse amongst our community of paddlers. Also, I’m going to use a few examples I saw this weekend, please if it was you don’t take it personally, but allow others to learn what you have obviously learned the hard way. As this part is pretty long, I’ll address other safety topics in separate threads.

First off, this isn’t a “don’t do as I’ve done” but rather learn from the wisdom of my past mistakes & be safe on the river. My first season in Colorado 10 years ago, I found myself going from a 4- paddler with a bomber roll, to luckily surviving a low skill, high bravado trip down the North Fork Payette less than 3 months later, thanks in entirety to an amazing group of safety conscious paddlers that prepared me & specifically Will Blount, who I ran it with. I checked off the NFP from the "Most Do" list before I ever knew there was a list, aka I had no idea what I was getting myself into, & I’m lucky to still be here. Way better prepared & skilled kayakers than I ever was, are no longer with us due to freak circumstances & one, a friend I lost last fall, sits with me daily & drives my internal thinking, “why her & not my idiot ass?” (posted in October 2010)

Alright, now to some goods…

When is it OK to swim?

Personally, I say never & it should only be as a last, absolute last resort. All you class 5 veterans understand this & know it is much more dangerous to be in the water than in your boat, and it’s only once all other options are exhausted that you will bail out of your kayak. The risk for entrapment, drowning, pins, etc., is infinitely higher when 90-95% of your body is in the water, versus 40-50% while you are in your boat.

As newer paddlers are coming up in skills, I think they mistakenly perceive going for a swim as a light undertaking, as they see the videos of the Beer Booties & the laughing it off afterwards as no big deal. What they don’t grasp however, is the fact that there generally is a well organized safety system in place with multiple fellow paddlers all skilled & practiced at hitting the swimmer on first throw of the bag, multiple Z-drag kits at the ready & able to be working in a minute or less, 1 or 2 safety kayakers on the water at the ready, & a well organized communication system.

Pickup groups organized at put-ins, take-outs or via the Buzz, don’t have this necessity for the most part, which instantly elevates the danger to a swimmer, as each kayaker unfamiliar with the others’ skills may take valuable minutes to “organize” a response, and although well intentioned, tends to be very poor in execution, with several either standing around not knowing what to do, or inadvertently getting in the way of those that do &/or putting them or the rescuers in further danger.

Not that I did this, but it is how I feel now before hoping on a section of water, the paddler should have a bombproof roll for whatever class of water he/she is paddling, & in a sense it should be a basis for determining what level of water he/she has the basic competence for running. He/she owes it to him/herself, their family & friends & as a courtesy to those they are paddling with. Swimming not only endangers the swimmer, but puts everyone else at an elevated risk as well. Hang tight, ride it out as long as possible, attempts as many rolls as you can, attempt & position yourself for a T-Rescue if need be, & only as a last resort exit your boat.

Incident at Pine Creek Hole (to be referenced in other Parts also).

On Saturday there were 7 of us running laps on the Numbers from just below Pine Creek Hole down, several of us were running Pine Creek as well, however when there was anyone running it, usually a pair or 3, there were two of us ready with bags just below the hole & 1 or 2 people in boats just downstream. We were a pickup crew from the a MB posting, & most of us had very little ideas of the others skill levels.

Our first go round resulted in a swimmer after the hole. Personally, I think he came out of his boat too early as I was manning a rope just above & he was in the slackwater & had flushed from the hole, see above.

Fortunately, with little incident we was out of the water after “triple falls”, again much too long in the water IMHO, boat secured & paddle later found thanks to the raft company photographer that tossed it up on shore. The kayak breached & filled on a rock about 20 feet from river right’s shore. The execution of the retrieval was not pretty, however we managed to get it free, but it did put some of us in unneeded danger. Of course, boat & kayaker ended up on opposite sides, again not pretty but we managed with trial & error, & most importantly due to all of us unfamiliar with our partners & their skill set, to unite kayak & paddler.

On lap #3, we arrived at the put-in parking lot to a group of 5 guys who looked well prepared to tackle Pine Creek. Later, we found out from the 2 who were without incident (see below), that it was a group of 3 & a group of 2 without connection to each other, not a group of 5 which all of us in our group had assumed. Minor chit-chat, and all “5” were heading up to the put-in, in addition 2 from our group were heading up as well.

Our group set up safety for our two paddlers, and as a courtesy, but without communication with the other “5” we were in position for when they came down. From our later discussion with the “2” we found out, the “3” had never run Pine Creek before, and tagged along with the “2”, i.e., peeled out right after them in tight formation with little pre-run conversation. Our two followed, however they were not “tagging a ride” & one had run it twice earlier with no incident, so they were slightly behind the “5”. Said “5” were in tight formation (another topic on this later). For a true group of 5, they were slightly closer than I would prefer, however as it was two different, unrelated groups, they were way too close to one another, less than 5 seconds apart.

Paddlers 1 & 2, of the group of 2, styled the left side sneak around the hole, paddler #3 (first of the group of 3) got botched up just above & fell into the meat of the hole with no speed & stuck. 5 seconds later, #4 dropped in on top of #3, then 5 seconds or less later #5 was on top of #3 & #4. #4 & #5 flushed out first, one of the two swam while in the slack water, & never looked for a rope on river right. I was first rope safety, I never threw as no one ever looked my way, & why would they if they never asked for anyone to run safety. Our number two rope safety, threw & was with 3 feet of the swimmer, but again the swimmer never looked for the rope & a quicker rescue was missed.

Our two paddlers (#6 & #7) came through without incident, avoiding the carnage in the hole, as they probably were 10-15 seconds behind #5. #3 (the first into the hole) flushed last, was in the slack water, & held tight in his boat, delayed in his roll attempts (see reason why below), attempted several while entering the rapids below & finally came out of his boat. I later saw him down at the river right bend, do the math on how long he was in the water after being beat up by his fellow boaters in the hole.

I initially thought our groups’ first timer was #3 (the guy starting the pileup in the hole) due to me thinking his travel partners blue boat was his, however I became aware this was not the case shortly after hearing the first reports of “a guy with all his teeth knocked out”. I’m pretty certain, #3, the first of the group of “3” was who in fact lost 3 of his teeth in the incident.

Let’s just say, it all turned into a clustereff afterwards. The group of two were heading downstream, they didn’t see the mess at the hole, nor were they “bound” to the tag-alongs, although I do believe they helped out at some point once they realized what was going on. Group of “3” only had one person still in a boat, two in the water, & probably the one in the boat needed some regroup time himself after the pileup. Leaving our group to help out in some fashion, I didn’t see much of what happened downstream, but nothing was pretty, although luckily all are still alive to tell the tale.

So many issues, failures, lapses of judgment, etc., that could be discussed, maybe another thread. Of all the conceivable causes, I think the most critical one was lack of communication, especially by the group of 3. Again like I said above, not assessing blame, as enough damage was done to the guy who lost all the teeth, but trying to use as an example, that will come up in some of my subsequent “Parts” on this safety discussion.

Safe boating all!

Hans is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old 05-23-2011   #2
Cpt. No Scout
idahofloater's Avatar
In a Van, Down By the River
Paddling Since: 91
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 517
I was too lazy to read all that. I fear part 2: Sorry.
idahofloater is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #3
tj@cu's Avatar
Boulder, Colorado
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 986
Wow, this one is hard to tackle, you kinda were bouncing ideas around that whole post. First off I think you have some of you numbers mixed up, as my friend was the one who got his teeth knocked out. He was not the first one in the hole (it was one of the "2" you mentioned, not in his group of "3"), he took the paddle of the paddler in the hole to the face then got boofed on. Shitty situation no doubt, I don't think it is unreasonable for a group to be that close together, it allows group members to be close enough to rescue each other.
I do think that you bring up a good point of better communication, it is always nice to know when and if someone wants a rope. I have boated with people who never wanted a rope until they swam and attempted to swim out of a hole a few times, and I have boated with people who want a rope the second they get stuck in a hole. At the same time I have seen people who throw their rope the second someone is stuck in a hole and people who maybe wait too long before throwing a rope.
The discussion of when to swim gets brought up all of the time, and is a personal choice. I have been stuck in a hole an swam within 5 seconds knowing that I wasn't going to get out of it or thought I wouldn't and I'm fine with that swim. I have also been in spots where I wasn't going to swim if I had to battle for minutes to get out (=locked in cali gorges). It has also happened when I held on too long and once I swam didn't have enough energy to get out of the river and if it wasn't for some good friends I wouldn't be typing this.
Glad you brought up the discussion of safety, it is something that some people don't like to talk about. You didn't seem to be personally attacking anyone but did seem that you don't agree with others taking a different level of risk than you.
glad everyone is OK minus a few teeth, but it makes him look like a hockey player and we all know the get all the chicks anyways.
tj@cu is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old 05-23-2011   #4
smauk2's Avatar
Near water (hopefully), Colorado
Paddling Since: 2008
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 770
Wow that was hard to keep straight. Makes me happy to own a full face.
smauk2 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #5
Gary E's Avatar
Jackson, Wyoming
Paddling Since: 94
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 745
Send a message via Yahoo to Gary E
I'm with Tom. I think swimming is a very personal choice. A lot of factors need to be determined. Fitness, swim if you pull, bad variables below, Pin that threatens boat integrity, you are the only one who knows whats going on with you and your gear. As far as distance apart, Tom is right you run close for safety. Safety does not have to be on shore.

No need to have a "bomber roll" to have fun. Swimming is part of the sport, hell I swam 2 years ago without even trying a roll, as it wouldn't have mattered and I wanted my shoulders. Don't police people you think you are better then. Hell I saw Rob lesser running jakes at 2000 in gear that looked to be from the 80's. As I sat in the rock drop eddy with some NF heavies all I heard was "hear comes royalty"... Looks are deceiving, so I would stop judging folks by gear or their decisions. We all have bad clothes and bad days.

If you don't like either of the above, then don't paddle with them. I would also say not paddling with someone on a class 4 run with no real dangers is kinda lame, but like i said earlier, we all get to make our own choices. Swimming happens, and sometimes me and the boys paddle into big drops we know we are gonna swim in (once again see above) It's kayaking, let people have fun and don't be so uptight about a few beatings, we all take em, some more then others....
Gary E is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #6
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 194
Holy carp. I want my 15 minutes back. Do they offer Threads on Tape? Next time I'll listen in my car during the NPR pledge drive. Ok, just kidding, but seriously. Two paragraphs just to announce the intention of the thread? And the meat of the thread read like a freak'n sudoku logic puzzle. Wait - who's in the 3rd red boat if number 2 of the 5 isn't looking for the 1st rope???

Besides - everyone ALREADY knows that too many newbies don't take swimming seriously - so why not sum up the novel and just say - "hey newbies out there, swimming isn't cool so please do everything you can to avoid it. Also, don't dive into another's group without asking. And don't follow to close. Oh - and to the people who created a cluster on Saturday at Pine Creek - this is meant for you."

As Elvis once said - a little less conversation and a little more action....
Does this condom make me look fat?
De la Boot is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #7
Arkansas during the off-season Nomadic during the summers! :), Arkansas & Colorado
Paddling Since: 2006
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 950
"I was first rope safety, I never threw as no one ever looked my way, & why would they if they never asked for anyone to run safety."

Sorry but this sounds really snobby. Remember, only the person in the situation really knows what he/she went through during the situation. Did he gulp water? was he fatigued? anything. So complaining he didn't look your way seems kinda picky.

I'm sure you know you try to get the attention of the swimmer by yelling ROPE. When I swim I am looking downstream first to see exactly what I need to do (aggressively swim, avoid a rock, cannonball a pour over)...So to expect them to "think of you first" by making eye contact with you without you yelling rope.

Also you decided not to throw or rather expected them to not want your help because they never asked you to run safety...I don't know you at all but if I see you swimming down river I will help if I can without you asking me!

Hope I didn't come off rude...remember we were all newbs in over our heads at one time or another.
gannon_w is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #8
Cphilli's Avatar
Copper Mountain, Colorado
Paddling Since: 2005
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 289
Doesn't have to do much with swimming, but I'm all about usage of the whistle on blind horizon lines now(was before too). Not even necessarily all of them, but particularly when there is a hole at the bottom that can surf you.

My injury earlier this season was from a blue angel run gone bad. You can always find things that led to said swim or accident after it happens. In my case I know we could have eddied out, taken turns, and made a quick whistle signal to go/stop.

Its always easy to point out the things you could have done differently "after" the accident though. Will always have my full face on when I creek from now on too.

Safety in general is extremely important(could go on forever about this), shit happens though.
Cphilli is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #9
Bend, Oregon
Paddling Since: 1993
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 143
I appreciate the focus on safety but its a bit extreme to equate swimming a class II riffle with swimming in class five. Swimming is almost inevitable so I would counter that you shouldn't run anything that you absolutely would not swim out of. Rather, practice swimming and safety regularly and make communication a priority whether you've just met some folks or they're your long time friends. I would say your dissertation was entirely a communication issue. Still, sounds like a bad day for a bunch of folks.
Vaya Con Rios!

MikeG is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2011   #10
glenn's Avatar
BZN, Montana
Paddling Since: 2008
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 1,493
It seems to me for the most part the mistakes made and the major consequences had nothing to do with pulling the cord in this case. Making a line, picking partners, river running style and communication all seemed to be contributing factors.
glenn is offline   Reply With Quote

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

Similar Threads
Topic Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
3/16/wed. Pine Creek-NUMBER's boof & BBQ fatbob Kayaking | Trip Planner 41 03-18-2011 11:25 AM
Pine & Numbers 2/24 Mike Hartley Kayaking | Trip Planner 0 02-23-2009 02:12 PM
day 2, 2009: Pine & #s Ken Vanatta Whitewater Kayaking 5 02-23-2009 01:36 PM
Utah BLM oil & gas sell-out— do your part. Chip Whitewater Kayaking 2 01-12-2009 04:42 PM
FIBArk 2008-One week away & Pine Creek Race info chixon Whitewater Kayaking 5 06-10-2008 09:56 AM

» Classified Ads
Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2019 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.