The Kelty Noah's 16 served us well last year on the Salt, Snake and a couple Rogue trips.
Good price for it here http://www.mountainsports.com/MSmain...&Detail=081992
The catenary cut is able to take strong winds as well as any other fly we've used in the past and this one is much lighter.
The 16' version set up on oars provided comfortable shelter for a full kitchen and eight people and it stood strong in a very violent storm in Hell's Canyon.
Only on the late September Rogue trip did we get wet under it.
Seems like being packed wet a couple days in a row somehow defeats the water resistance and we would have condensation drops form on the underside.
Someone mentioned restoring the water resistance with some kind of wash. What product is that and how is it used?