i have both, and my first choice is the villain.
I keep my super hero around for big water trips and as a surf and save boat. it lets me play, but i have the volume to help others if they swim.
I use my villain for harder runs and when the shit is serious. ie, narrows bailey etc.
I just like the speed and loose ness of the hull, sure i paddle harder to stay on line, but i like that about a creek boat.
the super hero is much easyer to keep on line, but it is also a slow boat compared to the villain. in my opinion.