Werner Werner Werner. In many years of paddling, I have never seen a Werner fiberglass paddle break. They also feel better to me than ATs. The one issue is wear on the blades. You will need a new one about every 2 years if you paddle alot.
Back to the original poster, why do you need a different paddle for creeking? I think that the Werner Player is great for creeking. I would rather use the same paddle all the time so that I am used to it. That said, I just bought a Sidekick (bigger blades) in the hopes that it will last longer given the wear factor.
My advice is to use the Player for creeking until the blades wear down, then buy another one.